“Moving from New York to New Orleans”

Bright Lights, Small City by Jami Attenberg

In New York City, as with most big cities, there is the opportunity to be anonymous on the streets. For a long time, I loved no one knowing who I was or what my business was. I took comfort in the speed with which I moved through the streets of the city, head down, in my own little world, but still somehow absorbing a thousand details at once. It was helpful to my development as an artist, I felt. If all you want is to be left alone with your imagination, then there is no better place to do it than New York.

In New Orleans, there is an insistence to the way we all interact with each other out in the world. We share these streets, which are generally sparsely populated in the neighborhoods. There are good mornings, goodnights, how y’all doings, and head nods and smiles and eye contact. There are neighbors who walk out on their front porch to give treats to my dog. There is polite chit-chat even if we don’t know each other. There are waves from car windows. There is communication. My solo-artist instincts still sometimes rise up, but here, I can’t hide even on those rare occasions I wish I could. This is me now: I’d rather be seen and known than ignored and isolated.

It’s not just the streets to which I feel more connected. It’s the entire city. Part of this might have to do with being a homeowner, and being more cognizant of public services, especially in a city that has a complex and dramatic past with hurricanes and flooding, government corruption, and troubled, antiquated utilities. (We’ve had several boil-water advisories recently, not to mention power outages all year long; I keep a store of emergency supplies for the first time in my life.) My awareness of public issues has increased exponentially because they impact me and my neighbors on a day-to-day basis. Local politics is everything here. I witness the struggle every day, I listen to the conversations—in my neighborhood of the Bywater, affordable housing is a hot topic—and I try to participate in this community as best I can, whether through contributing time or money. I even clean the catch basin on my street before it rains. The smallest of gestures reverberates in a city this size.

Klein and Sullivan on Political Tribalism

Andrew Sullivan and Ezra Klein have dueling pieces about the rise of political tribalism that rather directly call each other out.

Andrew Sullivan at New York Magazine: America’s New Religions

Everyone has a religion. It is, in fact, impossible not to have a religion if you are a human being. It’s in our genes and has expressed itself in every culture, in every age, including our own secularized husk of a society.

By religion, I mean something quite specific: a practice not a theory; a way of life that gives meaning, a meaning that cannot really be defended without recourse to some transcendent value, undying “Truth” or God (or gods).

Which is to say, even today’s atheists are expressing an attenuated form of religion. Their denial of any God is as absolute as others’ faith in God, and entails just as much a set of values to live by — including, for some, daily rituals like meditation, a form of prayer. (There’s a reason, I suspect, that many brilliant atheists, like my friends Bob Wright and Sam Harris are so influenced by Buddhism and practice Vipassana meditation and mindfulness. Buddhism’s genius is that it is a religion without God.)

Ezra Klein at Vox: The Political Tribalism of Andrew Sullivan

Sullivan is grappling for an explanation of rising political tribalism, and there, he may want to dispense with the introspection and explore the work of people who actually study it, like political scientist Lilliana Mason. Her work shows that groups’ behavior hardens when identities stack on top of each other and weakens when they pull in different directions.

All else being equal, a 62-year-old white, Christian Democrats who lives in rural Montana will loathe Republicans less than a 23-year-old Hispanic, agnostic Democrat who lives in Los Angeles. A young, conservative atheist will be more open toward liberals than a conservative evangelical (which neatly solves the mystery of Trump’s intense support among the Christian right).

Polarization is rising, and to the extent that Sullivan senses a hardening of tribal lines, he’s not wrong. But the driving force here isn’t the waning of Christianity but the politicized sorting of it, and much else. Married white Christians made up 80 percent of voters in the 1950s, and were evenly split between the two parties; today, they make up less than 40 percent of voters, and they’re overwhelmingly concentrated in the Republican Party. The parties have similarly organized around race, geography, and even age.

National Attention and Local Restaurants

If you haven’t seen this article on the effect of being labelled the “best burger in America” you should really read it at least for it’s sort of Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle in the Internet Age: You can’t observe something without changing it.

But I want to specifically draw attention to the conflict between localism and national excellence:

The Oregonian restaurant critic Michael Russell told me about a little ceviche place in Portland. Its chef Jose Luis de Cossio had cooked at the greatest ceviche restaurant in Peru, and opened fancy places in America, but tired of all that, and opened a tiny 23 seat ceviche place named Paiche in a desolate section of Southwest Portland. He’d wanted it to be small and serve the neighborhood and allow him time to surf and lead a balanced life.

But there was a problem: it was too good.

Willamette Week named Paiche its 2016 restaurant of the year. It made The Oregonian’s best restaurants list. Portland Monthly gave it a great review. Despite de Cossio’s wishes, it became a destination restaurant. So he changed it. He got rid of dinner service. And the ceviche. And made it just a breakfast and lunch cafe with a focus on coffee. He  wasn’t interested in serving the “narrow kind of customer” that populated his restaurant. He was more interested, he said, in returning it to the neighborhood.

…

Stanich explained that, as these issues were going on in the background, it was hard to read the social media screeds attacking them, and listen to the answering machine messages at the restaurant calling him a fat fuck and telling him to fuck himself for closing his own restaurant. He didn’t care about them, he insisted. He only cared about people like that woman who’d shown up, the regulars who live in NE Portland. “I need to take care of the people who took care of me,” he said. “They don’t turn on you.”

This was the same sentiment the chef at Paiche had expressed, and that I’d heard from others. If there was one main negative takeaway from the raging fires of food tourist culture and the lists fanning the flames, it was that the people crowding the restaurant were one time customers. They were there to check off a thing on a list, and put it on Instagram. They weren’t invested in the restaurant’s success, but instead in having a public facing opinion of a well known place. In other words, they had nothing to lose except money and the restaurant had nothing to gain except money, and that made the entire situation feel both precarious and a little gross.

Lodge 49

 

Vox reviews the breakout critical darling “Lodge 49.”

It’s not particularly easy to explain what Lodge 49 is about, because it’s not really like any other TV show I can think of. Its premise revolves around a Long Beach, California-based lodge maintained by a (fictional) fraternal order known as the Lynx. (Think the Masons or the Elks, but with a stronger record of gender and racial equality than those groups had.) The lodge is an all-purpose hangout for its members, but also seemingly a weirdo portal to some other, more purpose-driven life. It’s sort of, uh, Cheers meets Twin Peaks amid the ruins of late capitalism.

Lodge 49 uses this lodge as a window into the lives of its characters and the city of Long Beach, which is caught in transition between its working-class roots and its increasingly hipster-focused rebrand. (I used to live in Long Beach, which is perpetually in danger of becoming Los Angeles’s latest version of Brooklyn, though Silver Lake may have something to say about that.) But there’s also a lot of medieval symbolism and references to alchemy amid the tales of gentrifying neighborhoods.

…

What’s quietly beautiful about the show is how it positions the lodge — and by extension, a more community-based way of thinking about the universe — as the “other way to live” that Dud is looking for. It’s no good to live your best life if you don’t have others to live it with. Or, as Ernie puts it in “Sunday,” “What’s the use of living forever if you’re all alone on a Sunday?”

MTG Color Wheel and Tribalism

How the ‘Magic: The Gathering’ Color Wheel Explains Humanity

Often, a person who’s three colors won’t draw evenly from all three — for instance, someone who’s blue-black-red might identify heavily with blue-black’s growth mindset and red’s sense of presence and passion, but not particularly resonate with “creativity” or “independence.” But for the sake of argument, you could imagine a balanced trio as [the sum of its two-color connections] and [the absence of whatever the two remaining colors agree upon]. Some slightly cheesy and horoscope-y examples below (note that the cheesiness is because I’m trying to describe a general archetype, rather than pulling from specific subsets of each color as I would with a real, narrow example):

The Mainline Paradox: Memetics and Liberal Christian Collapse

evolutiontheorist's avatarevolutionistx

Warning: Just a theory

I wanted a graph that went back further in time, but this is what I found. Courtesy of Pew Research Center, “America’s Changing Religious Landscape”

Liberal Christian denominations (ie, Mainline Protestants) are caught in a paradox: even though they have increasingly defined themselves as open to everyone, their membership roles keep decreasing. It’s as if the more people they let in, the fewer people show up.

[insert Groucho Marx cartoon about not wanting to belong to the set of all clubs that would have him.]

Recent data from Minnesota highlights the precipitous decline:

Mainline Protestant churches have been hit the hardest. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) in Minnesota has lost almost 200,000 members since 2000 and about 150 churches. A third of the remaining 1,050 churches have fewer than 50 members. The United Methodist Church, the second largest Protestant denomination in Minnesota, has shuttered 65 churches since 2000.

Catholic membership statewide has held steady, but the number of churches…

View original post 1,624 more words

Gentrification Analogy

ozymandias's avatarThing of Things

Some of my upper-middle-class to upper-class YIMBY friends have said that they don’t understand at all why anyone would be upset by gentrification. This is an analogy I use which I think helps them understand.

—

Imagine your neighborhood is an actually functional community. You know your neighbors; you say “hi” to people when they walk down the street; you know people who will watch your cat when you’re on vacation, or tell you about jobs they’ve heard that you’d be perfect for, or play with your kid when you’ve had a really hard day and you need a break, or help you move, or give you casseroles when someone you love has died. (For some people, this is going to be a really difficult part of the thought experiment; you might want to imagine living near all your closest Internet friends.)

Now imagine that a bunch of billionaires have…

View original post 527 more words

Fractal Traditionalism

via Fractal Traditionalism

Linking this well written post less because of agreement (some things in it are right, some are wrong), but more because of how fascinating it is watching people who actually take “a return to traditionalism” and neo-reaction seriously… end up sounding like Marxist academics.

Like once you give up on claims to objective moral superiority (ie, the traditionalist fetish that one specific historical period is the source of all goodness), all you get is the acknowledgement that some times and places were more relatively stable, and we seek structural similarity to those periods rather than the “relatively superficial externals of food, clothing, language, public rituals, etc”. And also the realization that money and the unbridled pursuit of it are what disturbs such periods the most.

Unless you already assumed this guy was on your traditionalist side, it would be hard to tell the difference between him and the most Zizekian academic.

Dragon Knights

Duncan has a postmortem of the Dragon House, an attempt at an intentional community of rationalists modeled after military discipline. It caused a lot of controversy in rationalist tumblr circles a year ago, no one cares anymore, and the write up is not particularly good.

However it is the first message I saw of this terminology that I immediately found applicable to other tribal groups I had seen:

The White Knight is a role rather than a specific person; a role that various Dragons stepped into at various times (although there was one Dragon who was the White Knight something like an order of magnitude more often than any other). The White Knight is a character who has looked at what’s going on, built a model, decided that they understand the Rules, and has begun to take confident action in accordance with those Rules. In particular, the White Knight has decided that the time to choose stag is obvious, and is already common knowledge/has the Schelling nature. [“Stag” is Duncan’s term for costly cooperative effort.]

The White Knight is often wrong. Furthermore, other people often don’t notice that the White Knight is assuming that everyone knows it’s time to choose stag. So the White Knight burns resources over and over again, and feels defected on again and again, and meanwhile the other Dragons feel judged and found wanting according to a standard they never agreed to (remember, choosing rabbit should be the Schelling option, according to me), and the whole thing is very rough for everyone.

I saw this unfolding, took steps to point it out and to ameliorate it, but I didn’t do enough by half. The main thing that the White Knight needs to hear from the king (Commander) is “No. This is not the time or place to choose stag, whatever your preconceptions. If you choose stag now, you will lose resources, and you will feel betrayed, and some part of you will hold your fellow Dragons accountable for it and that’s not fair to them, either.”

…

Like the White Knight, the Red Knight is a role or character more than a real person. The Red Knight is a proponent of uncertainty, with an acute awareness of black swans. The Red Knight is a defender of individual freedom and personal sovereignty, and is wary of making commitments that might prove constraining or coercive. The Red Knight lives in fear of the White Knight’s judgment, or more specifically, in fear of being exposed to and vulnerable to the White Knight’s judgment. It’s not that the Red Knight is afraid of the White Knight so much as that the Red Knight wants to avoid the argument. The Red Knight does not want to be misunderstood about what it’s agreed to or how far it’s willing to go, and so it defaults to “no” over “yes.”

He also discusses a Black Knight, which is just a selfish rules-lawyer who follows the letter of the law but is never committed to the overall community spirit. But that cliche seemed much less common to me than the first two knights.

Not a JP Fan Blog

But some good threads about him at @Scholars_Stage

 

tgreer


His end message is pretty harmless. “The only thing we can be sure of in life is suffering. So do your part to make less of it.” And how do you operationalize that? Get a job. Clean your room. Go on dates. Have kids. Be responsible. Read Dostoevsky, Orwell, and the Bible.

Stop comparing yourself to others. Try to deal with people as people, not as demographic categories. Focus on building up your own character. Don’t expect life to be one chain of happy moments.

This is sooo not the end-of-the-world, devote yourself to destroying your enemies in the culture war sort of message I assumed it was going to be. Take out Orwell and Dostoevsky, and its essentially what you hear at any church worth its salt.

But it could have been that. And that is perhaps what I think the critics of Peterson don’t get. It could have been that. But its not–and we should be grateful for that.

So you are a 20-30 something man looking to live a purposeful life. You can’t look to religion, ‘cuz thats gone. You can’t look to your community, because that is gone too. What’s left? Well, our culture has sketched out three main paths:

1) The eternal man-boy. Life devoted to the man cave and the xbox live subscription.
2) The ally revolutionary. Life devoted to perpetual social justice agitation.
3) Sordid careerism. Life devoted to making money and climbing career ladders.

All three of those are pretty unfulfilling, though the devotees of each won’t admit it. You have a choice between one form of hollowness or another. And then you have some introverted types, or those who lack confidence, or what have you, who are not able to succeed in any of ’em

and you know, this is actually a kind of dicey situation. What happens to societies full of brooding, listless, hollow men? Men who can’t find a way to care about their communities, the people around them? Men who find no value in themselves? No value in the existing order?

Peterson provides a constructive way out of that. He helps them fill in the hollow spots. He’s not the only one to do this–I think, for example, of the incredibly successful podcast @TheArtOfCharm, which is a hit with the same demographic and for pretty similar reasons

Now @TheArtOfCharm is a bit more relationship and networking focused, but it hits all the same beats: he is how you improve your character. Here is how you find meaning in your life. Here is how you can be a man in this modern age when all of the rules seem to have disappeared.

And like Peterson, the AoC folks are a pretty compassionate lot–dealing with their audience as people, not as a demographic category.

But here is the thing to think about folks:

If these 20-30 year old men weren’t listening to Peterson, or to AoC, who *would* they be listening to?

This is one of the reasons I am genuinely *happy* @TheArtOfCharm exists. Because if you are not listening them, who do you go to for answers?

Well, you go to the Red Pill people. I don’t think I have ever encountered an online community that is as well…. *evil* as that one.

They really are that bad. But if they are the only one who offer answers, the only ones who speak real to this demographic… then what can you do?

Which is why I’m so happy the @TheArtofCharm exists. They meet the same need without the ugliness.

By & large that is all Peterson is doing. So before you get on the bandwagon and throw him onto the fire, just remember…. he could be saying something very different to his audience. He could be what his enemies actually say he is.


“He enables the alt-right!” some will say. I don’t think that is true–or at least I don’t see any evidence for it. But let’s say every single alt-righter reads listens to his lectures. Well, good! He will moderate them. His message is intentionally moderating.

But it did not have to be. He could actually be mobilizing his masses to rush into the culture wars. He could be trying to intensify all of that. But he really is doing the opposite. Care less about politics, read more old books is a big part of his shtick.

Now when it comes time to criticize him, I largely see two avenues (beyond the kind of unthinking knee jerking seen in some circles) of attack, neither of which I find particularly convincing. The first says that Peterson is and his message is just too 一般

I just don’t have any respect for the people who hate motivational works for just restating the obvious.

Look, the truth is: everything important that needs to be said about how to live the good life had already been said by 600 AD

If you are looking for revolutionary insights on how to be a good person, you will hear nothing new. Its been out there for millennia. There are only so many ways you can spin “Treat people like you want to be treated,””Don’t pin your happiness to other people’s opinions of you”

and so forth. In Church we sometimes call these stock things “sunday school answers.” But what churches understand, but intellectuals contemptuous of self-help do not, is that the people who actually live these things are the people who are constantly reminded of them.

We NEED to hear sunday school answers *every* week. Because forcing yourself to think through them regularly, and in different contexts, is what leads you to actually living them. Intellectuals get bored with all that, which is why so many are walking turd faces.

Now the second line of attack, well it isn’t really a line of attack. It is the one that frustrates m the most. It is the one that intensely dislikes the Peterson, AoC, Art of Manliness ecosystem of self help on demographic grounds.

You’ll hear people say “oh all the Peterson fanboys are white men, in their late 20s” as if that condemns him. It is almost as if his critics wish these people just didn’t have their own set of worries & insecurities about life–as if criticizing the people

who help them come to terms with these insecurities would get rid of the fact that they are there. And yeah, I your right, this group really has a better time of it than 99% of people have had it in all human history. Easy to dismiss their problems.

When you compare their problems to say, anyone living in Europe or Asia, 1937-1950, their struggle to find meaning and purpose is almost comical.

But that doesn’t mean it isn’t real. And real things have consequences.

You are not going to be able to banish this demographic. You are not going to be able to banish their insecurities. You are not going to banish their longing for meaning. And you certainly won’t be able to banish their identity as men.

The only question then is this: What will their identity as men lead them to do? What will their longing for meaning lead them to do?How will their insecurities shape who they will become?

Peterson has some answers for them.

If he wasn’t there, who would they be listening to?